Aah you're so cute!
Beautifulfreak, I had no idea (yes, I live under a rock) that you did makeup tutorials on Youtube! I love them! This is a really nice look...and one I'm never sure I can pull off. Maybe I'll try it soon!
MissMeliss- you sound like me! I only started wearing makeup at all when I was about 20, and I'm now 25. It's been something of an uphill battle, and I still get pretty lazy with it (as in, I don't wear makeup that often!).
As to your question, I would say that if you toned down the makeup somewhat (didn't pull it out toward your brows quite so much, kept it a little closer into the eye and eyelid area, and just did a bit of the white at the brows and such, and blended like crazy), and also if you weren't quite so dramatic with the eyeliner, I think natural eyelashes would suit this one just fine!
Personally, I'm not NEARLY this dramatic with my makeup! I love colour, I love playing with it, but it doesn't usually reach quite far out for me ;) Maybe I'll have to give that one a go!